About Books Reviews Read for Free Contact
← Back to Reviews
Books

All Things Cease to Appear

Elizabeth Brundage

Catherine Clare reluctantly trades life for a remote home in the tiny hamlet, after her husband lands a job teaching art history at a small college. Even as she does her best to transform the old dairy farm into a place where young daughter Franny will be happy, Catherine increasingly finds herself isolated and alone.

Score 9.0 / 10
MysteryCrimeDramaNoirFilm AdaptationAmerican

Mood

Focused

Pacing

Smooth

Aftertaste

In awe

Would Revisit

Sure thing!

Recommendation

Definitely recommend, especially to women!

Her mother had raised them to be good wives, diligent ones — this philosophy had carried the Sloane women through hard times, and Catherine had embraced it with a childlike enthusiasm. The women on her side were devoted mothers and wives. They distracted themselves from brief spells of gloom with cleaning, gardening, children. They clipped recipes from magazines and copied them onto index cards. They baked cakes in tins and made jelly and casseroles, cleaned out cupboards, reorganized drawers, ironed laundry, darned socks. They pleasured their husbands. They were Catholics with their own traditions — among them, the tradition of denial. (translated from Russian edition)

By tradition, I’ll start with the film adaptation — but this time I need to split it into two parts, because I watched the movie first, then discovered and read the book, and then rewatched the film. It was a completely different experience the second time.

Some things don’t change: the visuals, cast and performances are really nice, as is the setting. When I watched the movie for the first time, it didn’t seem as bad as its rating suggested. It has something of a ghost story in it, but also a psychological suspense element. I gave it 6.7/10 — not a bad movie, with a somewhat goofy ending, but the rest of it, especially the underlying meaning, seemed pretty good to me.

But after reading the book and rewatching the film, I was pretty furious. The adaptation suddenly looked so much worse — the creators did a really poor job bringing the story to screen, even though they already had everything they needed. I suspect a lot of it went to waste because it was made by Netflix, which is really sad given how great the book is. The movie is fine to watch if you haven’t read the book — if only to discover that it exists and go read it.

Now, to the book itself. The first 70+ pages are a bit hard to get through, because the story doesn’t start with the main characters and it can feel a little confusing. But after that it moves quickly and smoothly. It’s just something you have to push through.

The atmosphere is dark, heavy and at times even cruel in its content — and incredibly beautiful in its writing — as it tells the difficult story of a relationship between a man and a woman. Some parts may be hard to read due to the content, which includes not only emotional but also physical abuse.

This is a perfect story to illustrate what an abusive relationship actually looks like and how it can end for one of the people in it — unlike that unrealistic mess called It Ends With Us. I wish more people would find All Things Cease to Appear — it genuinely deserves far more attention and popularity than it has, and I’ll die on this hill.

There’s no mystery here: it’s very clear who did what and why — simply because he could. It’s a tragic story of a woman who didn’t want to believe her husband was a narcissistic psychopath, for a variety of reasons: patriarchal culture, unhealthy love, or perhaps dependency — financial, emotional, or otherwise.

Final Note

I'm really glad I found this book, bought it and read it. It's my book of 2025 without question. I definitely recommend it to everyone — 9/10, and huge gratitude to Elizabeth Brundage for such a masterpiece.

November 5, 2025
More to Explore
Cover for The Drama
Films

The Drama

Kristoffer Borgli, Ari Aster

A happily engaged couple is put to the test when an unexpected turn sends their wedding week off the rails.

DramaComedyRomance
Cover for Other Side of the Box
Films

Other Side of the Box

Caleb Phillips, Nick Tag

A couple receives a mysterious package from an old friend.

Short MovieHorror
Cover for The Collector
Books

The Collector

John Fowles

A lonely, dim-witted and deeply unpleasant young man unexpectedly wins a large sum of money in the lottery. What will he do with it — especially given his passion for collecting butterflies and his secret obsession with a local girl?

FictionPsychological ThrillerCrime